The 2026 Critics Choice Awards, held at 7 PM ET, witnessed drama as major star Cynthia Erivo notably missed the event following her omission from the nomination list. This absence comes as a shock to fans of the highly anticipated film Wicked: For Good, as Erivo has been a prominent figure in the franchise. While she has not publicly addressed her absence, she did share support for the film, which is nominated for seven awards, including Best Picture and Best Production Design.
Before the ceremony commenced, Erivo showcased her enthusiasm for the film via social media, sharing clips with her 3.8 million Instagram followers. This time last year, she was celebrated as a standout performer during awards season, having received nominations for the 2025 Critics Choice Awards and other major accolades, including the Academy Awards and Golden Globes.
Critics initially praised Erivo’s portrayal of Elphaba Thropp in the first installment of Wicked, but her reprisal in the sequel has not garnered the same level of acclaim. The competition for the Best Actress category this year is particularly fierce, with many critics favouring performances in smaller, independent dramas. The nominations for the Academy Awards will be revealed on January 22, 2026, but Erivo’s exclusion from the Critics Choice nominations, a frequent predictor of Oscar outcomes, has raised eyebrows.
Despite Erivo’s snub, her co-star, Ariana Grande, received a nomination for Best Supporting Actress for her role as Glinda the Good Witch. Grande attended the awards in an elegant off-white Dior gown, showcasing a new auburn hairstyle. In a heartfelt message to her 372 million Instagram followers after her nomination, Grande expressed gratitude for her creative team, stating, “My Glinda does not exist without the imprint of our remarkable leader Jon M. Chu or without being touched by my Elphaba, the singular Cynthia Erivo.”
Fans have reacted strongly to the Critics Choice Association’s (CCA) decision to exclude Erivo. Many expressed disappointment and confusion, especially in light of her commitment to the role, which included performing her own stunts and singing live on set. One fan remarked on social media, “It’s hard to understand how a performance as powerful as Cynthia Erivo’s was left out of the Critics Choice Awards nominations.” Another described the omission as “absolutely insane.”
The narrative of Wicked: For Good continues to delve into the complexities of Elphaba’s character as she navigates political isolation while fighting against the oppressive Wizard administration. Critics have noted this installment as darker and more intense, with some highlighting Erivo’s performance of the emotional number “No Good Deed” as “Oscar worthy.” This pivotal moment showcases her impressive vocal talent and dramatic flair, enhanced by a cast of flying monkeys.
Although overlooked by the CCA, Cynthia Erivo remains in contention for a Golden Globe in the Best Actress – Motion Picture Comedy or Musical category. Fans will have to wait until January 22 to see if her efforts in Wicked: For Good will earn her an Oscar nomination, but the excitement surrounding awards season continues to build.
