UPDATE: Comedians in Ireland are rallying for urgent action as the government delays the Arts (Recognition of Comedy) (Amendment) Bill 2024 for a staggering 18 months. This decision has sparked outrage among artists who argue that comedy deserves equal funding recognition alongside other art forms.
As the first sitting of the new Dáil commenced at Leinster House in Dublin today, Sinn Féin TD Aengus O Snodaigh addressed the critical need for legislative change. His bill seeks to amend the definition of “arts” to include “comedy,” a vital step towards ending the current exclusion of comedians from arts funding.
At a briefing event held on December 18, 2024, comedian Ailish McCarthy, who has been a vocal advocate for the bill, lamented the impact of this legislative blind spot. “Comedy is not a fringe pursuit, but a vital pillar of Irish artistic life,” she stated. McCarthy emphasized that the lack of funding has dire consequences, forcing many comedians to seek opportunities abroad, particularly in the UK.
The delay has been labeled as “exceptionally disappointing” by several TDs and senators, who argue that inserting one word into the bill should not take nearly two years. “It’s one word in a bill, so I don’t accept 18 months. It’s not good enough,” asserted TD Johnny Mythen.
The emotional toll of this delay was palpable as comedian Sinead Crilly, known as Shinanne Higgins, expressed her struggles. “It feels like for working-class people, there’s funding for all the nice violin players but none for those of us in arts that resonate more with the working class,” she said, highlighting the inequity in funding allocation.
Long-time comedian Ciaran McMahon, with over 20 years in the industry, shared the challenges of performing in Ireland, noting, “The hardest thing in the world to do is comedy in Ireland. It gets very competitive, and many comedians are forced to pitch shows under different titles just to get a foot in the door.”
The delay, criticized by O Snodaigh as “just delaying tactics,” has raised concerns among the comedy community. “There’s no reason for a delay, because it doesn’t happen overnight anyway in committee,” he added. Arts Minister Patrick O’Donovan has yet to provide a satisfactory explanation for the postponement.
The urgency for change is echoed by many in the comedy sector, who are calling for a legislative pathway that would allow them to access the same support as other art forms like theatre, dance, and music. McCarthy stated, “If this bill is passed, it sends the message: ‘stay, your work matters and your art belongs here.’”
This legislative battle highlights a significant cultural moment in Ireland, where humor and storytelling are deeply ingrained in the national identity. The call for inclusion in arts funding is more than just about money; it’s about recognition and respect for the craft.
As developments unfold, the comedy community and its supporters are determined to keep the pressure on officials, ensuring their voices are heard. The path ahead remains uncertain, but the urgency for action has never been clearer.
Stay tuned for updates on this developing story as comedians fight for their rightful place in the arts landscape of Ireland.
