Labour MP John McDonnell has suggested that Prime Minister Keir Starmer may choose to step down before he faces potential ousting from his position. This prediction comes amid growing concerns over Starmer’s leadership as Labour’s polling figures continue to decline and his approval ratings hit historic lows. Speculation is particularly heightened as the party prepares for the crucial local elections in May 2026.
Starmer’s leadership has come under scrutiny as Labour risks losing control of councils across England and devolved governments in Wales and Scotland. In recent months, many analysts have pointed to the upcoming elections as a pivotal moment that could determine the future of Starmer’s premiership.
Potential Candidates to Replace Starmer
In the event of Starmer’s resignation, several prominent figures within the party are anticipated to vie for leadership. These include Wes Streeting, the current Health Secretary, former Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, Andy Burnham, the Mayor of Manchester, and Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood. Each of these individuals is seen as a viable candidate to take over should the party seek new leadership.
Despite the mounting pressure, McDonnell believes that it is more likely Starmer will voluntarily step down rather than be forced out by party members. When asked about Starmer’s prospects as party leader in the coming year, McDonnell stated, “I’m like anybody else really, we will see what happens over the next six months, we will see what happens in the May elections.” He expressed confidence in Starmer’s ability to assess his suitability for the role, saying, “If he thinks after the May elections – if they are as disastrous as some people think… I think he’ll take the view himself.”
Labour’s Challenges and Future Prospects
McDonnell, who previously served as Shadow Chancellor, emphasized the importance of the government addressing pressing public concerns, particularly the ongoing cost of living crisis. He remarked, “If they demonstrated a steadiness in government and addressing the real issues that people are facing… I think there’s a prospect we could turn things around, but it could take longer than May.” His comments reflect a broader sentiment within the party that immediate and effective action is required to regain public support.
Starmer has faced moments of self-reflection during his tenure, admitting in a past interview that he considered resigning following the party’s disappointing performance in the 2021 local elections. He stated, “I did consider quitting because I didn’t feel that I should be bigger than the party and that if I couldn’t bring about the change, perhaps there should be a change.” Ultimately, Starmer resolved to remain in his position, committing himself to leading the necessary transformation within the Labour Party.
As the May elections approach, the political landscape remains uncertain, with Starmer’s leadership hanging in the balance. The outcome could not only influence the future of the Labour Party but also reshape the dynamics of British politics in the months to come.
