UPDATE: The Scottish Government’s refusal to support a crucial Bill aimed at criminalizing the purchase of sex has been labeled “absolutely shameful” by leading campaigners. Susan Smith, director of For Women Scotland, is calling for immediate action following the Government’s inaction on this critical legislation proposed by independent MSP Ash Regan.
The proposed Bill, which could impose fines of up to £10,000 or prison sentences for those convicted, aims to address the urgent issue of violence against women. Smith, who celebrated a landmark victory at the Supreme Court in April 2025, insists that the Bill could bring about “something real and practical” to combat exploitation.
Community safety minister Siobhian Brown previously stated that the Government “strongly supports the principle of legislating to criminalize purchasers of sex,” yet raised “significant concerns” about Regan’s proposals. Critics worry that the legislation could drive sex work underground, increasing risks for vulnerable individuals.
Smith countered these claims, stating, “While a lot of people will pay lip service to tackling violence against women, when pressed to act, they are running away from it.” She emphasized the unique opportunity the Government has to support Regan’s Bill, instead of merely suggesting amendments.
Regan highlighted the overwhelming support for her Bill, claiming endorsement from Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, and various women’s organizations. “Survivors and colleagues have expressed strong support for what they describe as a small but critical reform,” she said, pointing to the Government’s Equally Safe strategy as a framework for addressing violence against women.
She added, “There is deep concern that a Government which speaks so often of its commitment to Equally Safe could refuse to act on more than two decades of evidence.” Regan is currently in discussions about allowing MSPs a free vote on the so-called “Unbuyable” Bill, emphasizing the need for serious parliamentary debate on these critical issues.
A spokesperson for the Scottish Government reiterated their stance, stating, “The victims minister has made it clear that we support the criminalization of the purchasing of sex.” However, they reiterated concerns about the Bill as drafted, particularly regarding the safety of women.
As the debate intensifies, the pressure mounts on the Scottish Government to take definitive action. Smith’s passionate call to action resonates with many, as she declared, “I think that is shameful, it is absolutely shameful.”
As this story develops, it is crucial to watch for the Government’s next steps and the potential impact of this legislation on Scotland’s approach to women’s safety and rights.
